Reflections: Is AI the newest graven image
It’s nearly impossible these days to distance oneself from artificial intelligence (AI) in some form or other. While asking Siri to find directions or asking ChatGPT to summarize online content certainly saves time, there are concerns—for example, guidelines to ensure students are actually doing schoolwork, or repercussions from AI incorrectly summarizing an email. Some well-educated people in technical fields acknowledge a possible “point of singularity” at which humans cannot stop AI from making decisions that are actually harmful.
More recently, I’ve read several thoughtfully written essays about even deeper concerns of a spiritual nature: Basically, are we attempting to create an image of the human mind and soul—something only God can create?
At least one pastor has cloned an AI version of himself for congregation members to access for counseling, answers to Bible questions and more. That may be well-intentioned, as no pastor can be everywhere at the same time and some experience burnout trying to meet every congregant’s needs, but I personally wouldn’t want to head down the hospital corridor for surgery with AI praying for me. Can it know the condition of my soul, or sense my fear? Is it guided by the Holy Spirit? I think not.
Writing in Christianity Today, Chris Butler shares that concern, referring to the scriptural mandate in Hebrews 13:17 that leaders should keep watch “as those who will have to give an account” (BSB) over souls in their care. While an AI clone might scan sermons or scour the internet for advice, Butler writes that it “cannot, however, give that account to God. Nothing at all is at stake for it, and it answers to no one.”
Pope Leo XIV expressed similar concerns in his May 2026, encyclical, stating that AI must serve humanity, and not the other way around, because we are created in the image of God, and AI is not. He referred to the creativity humans possess as image-bearers, and the wrong-ness of AI usurping the creativity of others via their online presence without appropriate recognition.
With the Pope’s statement in mind, I was horrified to read another recent Christianity Today article, describing one of today’s most popular Christian singers as having “no soul.” The average consumer scrolling platforms for new music is likely to encounter, sometimes unknowingly, songs created by algorithms and machines. The article’s example is Solomon Ray, an AI-created artist climbing the charts.
True worship music is an expression of the human soul, and manipulating the mechanics of music just isn’t the same. The content creator defends his AI approach by calling it an extension of his own creativity—but, is it? It has obviously scoured the music of others for ideas and voicings. Even worse, there’s a REAL worship leader, a human one, with the same name, serving in a Montana church. That Solomon Ray asks, “How much of yourself are you pouring into this? The answer is, zero. God wants costly worship.”
Christian singer Forrest Frank agrees, saying the point of worship music is to open your heart to God: “It’s really weird to be opening your spirit to something that has no spirit.” Even the production side of things is relational—finding studio musicians whose passion and talent match your vision for the music, interacting with engineers and producers. When my son-in-law recorded an album of his original music, those relationships helped make it a memorable experience.
Do we risk violating the Second Commandment by making an “image” of human creativity? Especially if we allow it to displace uniquely human characteristics or, worse, consider it a source of wisdom?
The National Association of Evangelicals considers this a serious enough situation that they have adopted a resolution which “recognizes [AI’s] immense potential for good,” while also calling for “guardrails” of respect for the image of God—the dignity conferred upon humans as part of Imago Dei (Genesis 1:27) and not by anyone or anything else. AI can imitate some functions of the mind, says the NAE, but it possesses “no conscience, no love, no soul.”
Given those concerns, the NAE urges AI use that serves that image, including the God-given potential for productive labor, saying, “Gains in productivity should not be purchased by discarding the worker made in God’s image.” In the music example, AI probably saves money, but what about the studio musician praying for sufficient work to support his family and hearing some of his earlier work, without compensation or credit, on an AI production?
In short, it’s a complicated question. In seeking to use AI wisely, we must constantly return to God’s Word, which tells us in James 1:5 (BSB), “If anyone lacks wisdom, ask God.” Don’t ask AI.



![Blood type legacy [Part 2]](https://static.wixstatic.com/media/0d906d_9be3371f55b9448d8786e3635525e1cb~mv2.jpg/v1/fill/w_230,h_230,al_c,q_80,enc_avif,quality_auto/0d906d_9be3371f55b9448d8786e3635525e1cb~mv2.jpg)

Comments